The reparations debate

Sunday 18 October, 11:00—12:30, Abbey Room, Church HouseContemporary Controversies

The arguments about reparations seem to be moving up a gear. Britain is facing a potential slavery reparations lawsuit from Caribbean nations. The issue is due to be raised at the Commonwealth summit hosted in Antigua in November, which King Charles is set to attend. Jamaica’s culture minister, Olivia Grange, has travelled to London to seek an audience with the king, who remains head of state of Jamaica, to petition him to request advice from the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, the Caribbean island’s highest court of appeal, on three questions related to chattel slavery: first, whether enslavement was legal under English law; second, whether international law was breached; third, whether there is a present-day legal duty to provide redress.

Earlier this year, 123 nations voted for a landmark UN resolution that described chattel slavery as the gravest crime against humanity. The UK was one of several European countries that abstained from voting in the resolution. But since then, a UN committee on the elimination of racial discrimination said countries are legally obliged to consider reparations for the transatlantic slave trade and take other ⁠measures to address the enduring ⁠legacy of racial discrimination.

Those demanding reparations have been cheered on here in Britain – by loud but influential figures, from an informal, cross-party group of MPs and Lords, the All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on African Reparations, to leaders of a range of British cultural and academics institutions and NGOs who feel embarrassed about the UK’s history and culture. The Green Party of England and Wales says there will be ‘no true peace and justice’ until Britain and other European countries ‘atone for the crimes they are still benefiting from… and the ongoing impact’. It is such people who encourage Jamaican leaders to act opportunistically, even at the expense of their own country’s economic interests.

Conversely, white guilt is not something felt by most people: according to a recent YouGov poll, 60 per cent do not support reparations and just 24 per cent do. The responses reveal divisions along lines of ethnicity and political-party support. Andy Burnham’s government has stated the country will not pay reparations. Reform’s home affairs spokesperson, Zia Yusuf, has said the ‘bank is closed’ to anyone aiming ‘use history as a weapon to drain our Treasury’, claiming the UK is being ‘ridiculed on the world stage’.

But the prime minister of Barbados, Mia Mottley, is disdainful: ‘Those who want to preach morality, and those who want to tell us about good governance, who want to create the illusion of appropriateness, goodness, purity – the language associated with “white” are the ones “perpetrating a mockery”.’ 

Are reparations a necessary moral response when dealing with past ‘crimes’ or are they too easy an attempt to buy absolution for historic wrongdoings – another ‘white saviour’ project, driven by guilt? Should Britain’s role in abolishing slavery and creating a universal standard of human equality in the political realm be a consideration? Or do critics of reparations fail to take seriously the legacy of the slave trade, and the link between the oppression of black people in centuries gone by and the negative impact on Caribbean countries or the discrimination suffered by some here in Britain today?