Do we know our enemy? Untangling terrorism and extremism

Sunday 18 October, 15:45—17:00, Assembly Hall, Church HouseKeynote Controversies

On the twenty-fifth anniversary of 9/11, Prime Minister Andy Burnham said, ‘terror still knocks on the door of democracy’, but that those who seek to destroy shared values ‘will never win’. But are we clear what constitutes terrorism anymore, or who threatens our values?

The murder of 3,000 people in New York was a pivotal moment: the world grasped the threat jihadi Islamism posed to the West, and the war on terror became policy. In 2026, we seem less sure what threatens the UK, or even what values we hold. Some British schools now even avoid teaching 9/11 for fear of stirring ‘anti-Muslim hatred’, while jihadi attitudes to Israel and the ‘colonial West’ have become fashionable on British campuses and London streets.

After the Islamic State’s Manchester Arena bombing, politicians and commentators urged the public: ‘Don’t look back in anger.’ But while there’s been a seeming reluctance to confront or even name the rise of Islamism, there is a growing clamour against allegedly far-right terror – despite official evidence that Islamism remains the primary domestic threat. How else to explain twice as many Prevent referrals for the extreme right as for radical Islam? Does this imply a politicised reluctance to name the enemy?

Confusion has deepened with the government’s controversial proscription of Palestine Action as a terrorist organisation. Official figures for the year to March 2026 show 3,061 terrorism-related arrests, 92 per cent linked to public support for the group at protests – including holding ‘I oppose genocide’ signs. Ever-wider terrorism powers are increasingly used against speech, journalism and unpopular opinions, though most such cases never result in terrorism charges. Do such official actions undermine and trivialise the real threat of terrorism?

Meanwhile, politicians increasingly target extremism, a far broader category, as a supposed precursor to terror. Labour’s manifesto promised to update counter-extremism rules, including online, to ‘stop people being radicalised and drawn towards hateful ideology’. But what constitutes ‘hateful’ and is there a danger such an approach makes society more censorious rather than safer?

A recently leaked memo showed that the Home Office’s anti-extremism unit, RICU, monitored Charlie Kirk’s supporters after his assassination, warning they could use his murder to ‘push pro-free-speech narratives’. Similarly, the danger of such catch-all rhetoric was exposed when Policy Exchange published sections of advice given to the government about warning signs of dangerous extremism, which included everything from ‘spreading misinformation and conspiracy theories’, to an interest in ‘an online subculture called the manosphere’.

Some warn such linguistic mission-creep might mean more people are labelled ‘the enemy within’ and undermine legitimate hostility to state failures and government policies. In an era of visceral – if often righteous – grievances about everything from small-boat crossings to rape grooming gangs, is there a danger that more such elastic definitions could be used to brand more and more citizens as would-be terrorists?

Or should we be concerned about the descent of environmentalism into radicalised Green, anti-Israel fanaticism or the campaign for transgender rights radicalised into intimidatory, anti-women activism? Does the appearance of black-clad, balaclava-wearing ‘vigilantes’ such as Patriot Platform already cross the line? And while political violence is not a normalised feature of British public life, should the murder of Reform UK’s Ann Widdecombe or reports of rising harassment and intimidation of elected politicians make us reassess who the enemy is?

Finally, as the Institute for Strategic Dialogue identifies new forms of extremism – attacks such as Axel Rudakubana’s brutal murder of those three little girls in Southport – driven less by a defined ideology than by nihilism and a fascination with violence itself – is it even possible to identify the enemies we face?

Or is all this generalised political focus on myriad threats too bleak a view? While MI5 and security services should monitor and act to keep us safe, are we in danger of seeing ever-increasing numbers of our fellow citizens as ‘the enemy’? How do we balance out sensible precautions from succumbing to a misanthropic culture of fear that risks social solidarity?