Sanctioning Israel: principle or prejudice?
In September, the British government dramatically stepped up pressure on Israel. The foreign secretary, Ed Miliband, announced plans to ban imports from Israeli settlements in the West Bank, sanction companies and individuals involved in settlement expansion and prevent the advertising of settlement property in Britain. Arms-export restrictions will also be tightened. Miliband called out Israel for ‘ethnic cleansing’ as part of the justification and claimed Israel’s actions make a ‘two-state solution’ all but impossible.
Both Israeli and British-Jewish representatives responded with severe, uncompromising criticisms. Israel accused the UK of being ‘on the wrong side of history’ and of interfering in its upcoming elections, and announced targeted responses, including the closure of the British consulate in East Jerusalem. In Britain, the chief rabbi, Sir Ephraim Mirvis, called the sanctions ‘a dark day for British Jews’ and warned that they would bolster the very extremism they were supposed to confront.
Supporters of the sanctions argue that settlement expansion is making a future Palestinian state increasingly impossible. If Britain believes in a two-state solution, they ask, shouldn’t it be prepared to do more than issue condemnations? Critics counter that the sanctions are largely symbolic: settlement goods comprise a tiny share of Israeli exports, while Britain continues extensive trade and security cooperation with Israel. Is this principled foreign policy, or gesture politics aimed at demonstrating moral virtue? Some argue it could be worse than mere virtue-signalling: it has emerged that Andy Burnham overruled advice from the Foreign Office and intelligence services that such sanctions could put at risk crucial intelligence-sharing operations. Has the desire to achieve a clear moral message taken precedence over hard-nosed geopolitical necessity?
There is also a wider question about Israel’s changing relationship with the West. Since 7 October 2023, Israel has found itself increasingly condemned and isolated even while confronting Hamas, Hezbollah and the threat from Iran. Are Western governments legitimately holding an ally to account, or is Israel being subjected to standards rarely applied to other states? Does distinguishing between Israel and the settlements provide a sensible middle course, or does the growing resort to sanctions risk feeding a broader campaign to turn Israel into an international pariah?
Will sanctions bring peace any closer? Or are they more a cheap way of demonstrating that Britain, and the Labour Party, are ‘taking a stand’ against everyone’s favourite international villain? Are the sanctions genuinely a question of morality, or should geopolitical considerations weigh on such decisions?



