Middlesbrough: what just happened?
In the early hours of 22 August, a Volkswagen Passat tore the wrong way down the A66 and smashed into a Cleveland Police armed-response car. Two police officers – PCs Tom Clough and Matthew Blades – were killed, along with the five young men in the Passat, several of whom had prior convictions for assaulting police. While community leaders appealed for calm, there was an immediate escalation in gang violence, with houses rammed, cars torched, and Middlesbrough revealed as a town living in the shadow of a gangland siege. The father of one of the five young men has been charged with assaulting someone at his own son’s funeral.
Residents talk of no-go streets, of balaclava-clad youths on quads and e-bikes, of being too frightened to walk after dark or to phone the police. Instead of a show of grief for the youngsters, some locals expressed relief. One local resident condemned ‘a bunch of kids who think they’re above the law and can do what they want’. Another said, ‘people don’t feel safe in Middlesbrough centre’.
Cleveland records some of the highest crime rates in England and Wales. Locals say the social contract has broken down. In its place is a cohort of young men who appear to regard themselves as outside civil society, treating the agents of the state with open contempt. But is this new? Back in 1993, 11-year old ‘Balaclava Boy’ from neighbouring Hartlepool appeared on the front pages of national newspapers wearing a ski-mask and giving a V-sign after crashing a stolen car.
Indeed, leading commentators insist that crime is a story of perception rather than fact. Fraser Nelson has long argued that the Crime Survey shows Britain becoming safer, not more violent. Sadiq Khan points to falling homicide in London and accuses critics of peddling disinformation and talking the country down. Yet in some places like Middlesbrough, ordinary lived experience is of lawlessness that is brazen, local and unchecked. Actually, this is not just about Middlesbrough. It can be seen in towns up and down the country.
When everyday criminality and disorder is deprioritised, communities learn that rules are optional. When the police finally flooded the streets after two of their own were killed, it looked to some as if the police were taking revenge, which only deepened the very contempt that they are trying to contain. As one resident said, ‘the police have ignored the problems in the area for years and done nothing’. Now they are clamping down, but it all seems too little, too late.
But when people no longer believe the authorities will act, is it really the case that there will be a collapse of the idea that we inhabit a shared civic order? Is it the case that we only kept on the straight and narrow by the Thin Blue Line of a benign state? Is neighbourhood criminality caused by deprivation, family breakdown, lack of employment… in which case, why now? What are the chances of rebuilding communities in towns and cities, and perhaps the country, if we cannot reassert the most basic rules of living together?



