From surveillance to censorship: rolling back the laws

Sunday 18 October, 15:45—17:00, Council Room, Church HouseTech Futures

In association with:

It’s increasingly accepted that Britain is going through a free-speech recession. The cumulative effect of speech-restricting laws means government has extraordinarily broad powers, with few checks and balances. As a consequence, ‘speech crimes’ mean you can be arrested, prosecuted, convicted, imprisoned – all for things you’ve said.

Indeed, a new Big Brother Watch (BBW) report, Britain’s Free Speech Problem: How growing restrictions are stifling speech online and offline, has exposed that at least 62,199 people in the UK were arrested for communications offences over five years. It also provides evidence of a ‘postcode lottery’ of speech policing: some police forces made 14 times the number of per capita arrests than their neighbours, reflecting the elasticity of vaguely defined speech offences in UK law. BBW concludes: ‘We believe the UK needs a free speech reset’ after its investigations revealed that a relentless stream of new restrictions is limiting free speech, as well as normalising state surveillance and restrictions on protest.

For example, the report illustrates serious problems with the Online Safety Act in relation to digital ID. It has led to videos from mainstream political parties, posts on British history and paintings by famous artists being blocked or age-gated online; posts on BBC News, reports about the war in Gaza and discussion of 1970s punk bands have all been hidden behind demands for ID.

Meanwhile two new major laws – Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 and Public Order Act 2023 – have placed draconian limits on protest rights. The National Security Online Information Team now operates with virtually no scrutiny, monitors public reactions to everything from the 2024 riots to the general election and flags problematic content to social-media companies.

Some free-speech campaigners are less convinced that conflating protest rights or concerns about digital ID and surveillance with fighting for free expression is a useful tactic. Regardless, BBW has called for government to commission an independent national review into the cumulative impact of legislation governing online speech, communications offences and protest, and make recommendations to ensure that fundamental rights are protected.

Elsewhere, a recent Prosperity Institute paper, Reversing Britain’s Free Speech Recession, by barrister Jon Holbrook traces the story of free-speech restrictions historically. He argues that the 1965 Race Relations Act first established that the state could criminalise a particular kind of political belief. Then the Public Order Act 1986 criminalised words that were ‘likely to cause harassment, alarm or distress’, a legal threshold much lower than had previously existed and established that the state had a right to limit speech that threatened to cause neither a breach of the peace nor violence.

Holbrook’s solution takes the form of five specific proposals to roll back the whole mass of restrictions built up over 60 years: repealing bad criminal law and replacing a tangle of overlapping communications offences with a single, tightly drawn provision; sweeping away hate-speech law entirely; and giving free speech proper protection in the civil courts through a new tort and a sensible costs regime.

More contentiously, Holbrook argues that Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), often cited positively by free-speech campaigners such as BBW, provides no real shield against the rise of hate speech law, and suggests there is no alternative but to leave the ECHR altogether.

How best to unpick and overturn decades of regressive law-making? If rolling back legislative overreach becomes the focus of campaigning, might it distract from challenging the broader culture that assumes the only way to defeat toxic ideas is through censorship rather than debate?