Benjamin Britten, 50 years on: still the nation’s composer?

Sunday 18 October, 10:00—10:45, Westminster Room, Church HouseBreakfast Banters

‘Despite his reputation as a conservative, Britten is still the essential figure of British Music’, wrote Ivan Hewett recently in the Telegraph. But according to composer Oliver Rudland, while this is a ‘typical viewpoint’, it is an example of ‘entirely muddled thinking’. According to Rudland, ‘It is precisely because, in a deeper artistic sense, Britten was conservative that his music remains essential’. Certainly, unlike the many more radical British composers that have followed in his wake, Britten never dispensed with traditionally informed melody and harmony, and it is precisely this, it is argued, that accounts for his enduring popularity, and the frequency of stagings of his operas – which outstrip any composer working in the past 50 years since his death.

The Royal College of Music (where Britten studied) famously prevented him from becoming an apprentice of the European Modernist Alban Berg, which Britten acknowledged later in life as a positive intervention, and one that allowed him to discover his own artistic path. On this path, Britten brought ‘loving expression to England’s gentle arcadia, its history and its institutions’, which formed the basis for his astonishingly successful operatic output. What was unique here was that unlike, say, Elgar or Vaughan Williams, Britten was able to bring these feelings into the theatre. From the medieval Christian parable depicted in Curlew River (1964) to the comic local constabulary dramatised in Albert Herring (1947), Britten did what all great opera composers do: he conjured a panoramic and holistic artistic picture of his native culture, that of East Anglia.

So is conservativism in musical form, and perhaps politically in terms of a deep connection with the nation, the spur for great art? Are all modernist, European, even universal attempts at breaking free from traditional and national boundaries really negative influences on musical composition? And what explains Benjamin Britten’s continued popularity in thoroughly modern Britain, but well beyond these shores, too?