Things in schools certainly are changing. Countless education related inquiries (the Assessment Inquiry, the Primary Review and the Good Childhood Inquiry to mention just a few) – let alone the Children’s Plan - promise major changes in schools and what it will mean to teach in the 21st century. There is similarly a growing array of research programmes competing to try and influence educators and sell their evidence - often contradictory - as the most reliable guide to ‘best practice’. The ESRC Teaching and Learning Research Programme has suggested teachers follow evidence-based commandments (the ten principles of pedagogy).
These evidence-based policies now target an ever expanding number of people involved in the educational process. Education is increasingly ‘outsourced’ to learning guides, support assistants and other ‘key workers’ who facilitate and mentor children to create their own learning outcomes. Teachers working alongside them face new demands for ‘continuing professional development’ in childcare and identifying children’s needs, as well as pressures to consider ideas such as ‘neuro-linguistic programming’ to increase their effectiveness as ‘classroom practitioners’.
Such a confusing scene begs questions about what teachers are for these days. Is a teacher a distinctive academic professional anymore or just one of an array of caring neo-professionals supporting the welfare of the child? Is making teaching a more research-informed profession the best alternative to much-decried ‘here one day, gone the next’ policies and initiatives? Or is evidence-informed pedagogy too narrow and prescriptive an approach to allow for teachers’ autonomy and creativity?
Author of best selling teacher-training texts Teaching Today and Evidence Based Teaching.
professor, education and social inclusion, University of Birmingham; contributing author, When Tomorrow Comes: the future of local public services
chair of policy and research committee, General Teaching Council for England; author, Managing Targets and Managing Value Added
|Dr Mark Taylor
assistant head of school, Addey and Stanhope comprehensive school; London convenor, IoI Education Forum
How bad is it? Five million of us are leaving school without having mastered basic literacyHoward Jacobson, The Independent, 9 August 2008
Phil Beadle separates facts from opinion on the subject of adult literacyPhil Beadle, The Guardian, 5 August 2008
Kathryn Ecclestone & Dennis Hayes, Routledge, 4 July 2008
General Teaching Council advice to Government and response to the 2020 Vision report.The General Teaching Council for England, March 2007
Geoff Petty, Nelson Thornes, 21 August 2006
A teacher's guide to research evidence on teaching and learningTeaching and Learning Research Programme
"…the most interesting, diverse, serious and argumentative audience imaginable."
Prof Sir Bernard Crick