The China and human rights controversy
"Western democracies should take every opportunity, including the Beijing Olympics, to pressurise China to improve its human rights record"
Saturday 12 July, 10.15am until 11.00am, Norton Rose LLP The Battle for China

Two speakers will exchange opposing arguments before Q & A from the audience

In the run-up to the Olympic Games in Beijing, many critics have called for a boycott of some kind to show revulsion at China’s support for the Sudanese regime, its disregard for human rights, and its treatment of Tibet. Film director Steven Spielberg pulled out of his role as artistic adviser to Beijing 2008 over China’s ‘unspeakable crimes’ in Darfur. Actors George Clooney and Mia Farrow have joined the likes of former UK sports minister Kate Hoey MP and NGO ‘Reporters sans Frontiers’, in slating China for allegedly funding ‘Khartoum’s genocide’ and oppressing Tibetans. There is even a growing international campaign to brand these ‘The Genocide Olympics’, a slogan coined by Farrow in a Wall Street Journal opinion piece written with her 19-year-old son Ronan last year.

But what about the other side of the argument? An opinion piece in the People’s Daily in January angrily fought back against the politicisation of the Games, arguing that China will not be cowed by Hollywood stars: ‘If at each subsequent Olympics people stand up and use politics to maliciously attack the host nation, and use ideology to draw up boycotts, where does that leave the Olympic spirit?’. Other critics argue that the West has no right to lecture China on human rights anyway. So, should we keep politics out of sport? Are calls for a boycott based on political principle, or hypocritical moral posturing? Should the Olympics be used to ‘bash’ China or are they an opportunity to put the regime under international pressure to reform?

 Speakers
Brendan O'Neill
editor, spiked; author, Can I Recycle My Granny and 39 Other Eco-Dilemmas
Minky Worden
media director, Human Rights Watch; co-editor of Torture; editor of China’s Great Leap: The Beijing Games and Olympian Human Rights Challenges
Chair:
Ceri Dingle
director, WORLDwrite, WORLDbytes and Chew On It productions


 Recommended readings
The People’s Republic is learning presentational skills

As for Tibet, I was in Beijing and other cities in the period of the recent confrontation in Lhasa and elsewhere. The general opinion of taxi drivers was that the economic development of Tibet should have made this a non-issue and still might.

Alan Hudson, Culture Wars, 10 July 2008

Beijing 2008 – Stop the sport of China-bashing

Racism and hypocrisy lie behind the approach of western politicians, campaigners and celebrities towards China.

Chandran Nair, Ethical Corporation Magazine, 10 June 2008

China's Great Leap: The Beijing Games and Olympian Human Rights Challenges

An essential book for understanding China on the cusp of the Olympics, China's Great Leap draws on the expertise of many of the world's leading China experts. These writers examine the People's Republic of China today as its government and 1.3 billion people prepare for the 2008 Olympic Games.

Minky Worden, Seven Stories Press, 8 May 2008


Turning China into a whipping boy

A debate about the Olympics sent out a clear message: Britain may no longer be Great, but at least we aren’t China.

Tim Black, spiked, 21 April 2008

From Olympia to impasse

China and the west are almost matching each for sheer incompetence and hypocrisy over the Beijing Olympics

Dominique Moisi, Guardian Unlimited, 20 April 2008

The new Olympic sport: China bashing

China is blamed for everything from human rights abuses to pollution and rising food prices

Mick Hume, The Times, 18 April 2008

Amid human rights protests, a look at China's record

Freedoms have improved tremendously in the past 25 years, but Chinese people today face plenty of red lines.

Peter Ford, The Christian Science Monitor, 10 April 2008

Using Tibet to settle scores with China

Tibetans want to be free. But they’ve been given a green light to riot by Western elements driven more by spite and envy than a love for liberty.

Brendan O'Neill, spiked, 17 March 2008

And the gold medal for China-bashing goes to…

The Beijing Olympics have been turned into an all-purpose platform for panicmongering about the Yellow Peril. We name the culprits.

Brendan O'Neill, spiked, 14 February 2008

Culture is no excuse for China denying its people democracy

Repressive regimes are playing on our colonial guilt, but we must stand up for those values to which oppressed people aspire.

Ian Buruma, The Observer, 3 February 2008

Come on, Mr Brown, stand up to the Chinese

After the end of the Cold War, it seemed that democracy was on the march.

Will Hutton, The Observer, 20 January 2008

 Session partners





 in association with