Do anti-bullying policies build character?

Sunday 18 October, 12.00 until 13.00, Pit Theatre, Barbican Battle for the Classroom

In January, the Department for Education announced an awards scheme for schools that teach perseverance, resilience and grit. The education secretary, Nicky Morgan, declared: ‘As well as high academic standards, this means providing opportunities for all young people to develop the character and resilience they need to succeed in modern Britain.’ Yet this move comes in the context of a proliferation of anti-bullying policies, which seem to imply children are in need of constant protection from not only violent bullies, but from childish nastiness. Can children really develop character and resilience if they are to be protected from the unpleasant experiences that have traditionally been seen as rites of passage?

Over the past decade, there has been more than a six-fold increase in peer-reviewed research on bullying. Tellingly, this research reveals that definitions of bullying are broad-brush and include ‘teasing and name-calling’, ‘spreading rumours’ and ‘exclusion at playtime or from social events and networks’.  It is claimed that ‘emotional bullying can be more damaging than physical’. More and more forms of bullying are being discovered and powers to intervene are on the rise. The Education Act of 2011 gives teachers stronger powers to tackle cyber-bullying by providing a specific power to search for and delete inappropriate images or files on electronic devices and mobile phones. Government now provides advice for spotting sexist, sexual, homophobic and transphobic bullying. There is even official advice on protecting teachers from being bullied by their pupils.

Is there a danger, as some sceptics argue, that ubiquitous anti-bullying initiatives make children fearful of interactions with their friends and contributes to a generation of ‘cotton wool’ kids? Are we actually denying children the ability to develop ‘grit’ and ‘resilience’ by removing the informal ways in which children develop character through their ordinary interactions with each other? Indeed, are initiatives to teach character actually a sticking plaster to deal with the problems that have been created by anti-bullying policies?

More broadly, why have schools, policymakers, the media and academia become so preoccupied with bullying? Is it a necessary corrective to the way that life-diminishing incidents of bullying were ignored in the past, or a sign of excessive adult concern with normal childhood interaction? Indeed, what is ‘bullying’? Is it straightforward to distinguish everyday conflicts or disagreements from genuinely unacceptable bullying?

Watch the debate
Listen to the debate

Speakers
Professor Mike Boulton
professor of psychology, University of Chester; researcher, bully-victim relationships and psychological well-being

Dr Helene Guldberg
director, spiked; author, Reclaiming Childhood: freedom and play in an age of fear and Just Another Ape?

Keith Sullivan
retired educational psychologist and university professor, National University of Ireland; author, The Anti-Bullying Handbook

Chair
Kathryn Ecclestone
professor of education, University of Sheffield; author, Governing Vulnerable Subjects in a Therapeutic Age (forthcoming)

Produced by
Dr Helene Guldberg director, spiked; author, Reclaiming Childhood: freedom and play in an age of fear and Just Another Ape?
Recommended readings
Cyberbullying is harmful. But old-school harassment feels worse

New technologies bring new ways for humans to make life miserable for one another. But using the latest digital tools to bully doesn’t cause as much emotional harm as what’s been taking place on schoolyards for years.

Elahe Izadi, Washington Post, 4 June 2015

What Tactics Motivate Bullies to Stop Bullying?

University of California researchers identify new strategies to reduce bullying.

Christopher Bergland, Psychology Today, 3 April 2014

How do other countries tackle bullying?

From KiVa in Finland to police collaboration in America, Rebecca Ratcliffe explores how schools and educators across the globe are tackling bullying.

Rebecca Ratcliffe, The Times, 20 November 2013

Bullying can be good for you

spiked podcast talks to Helene Guldberg about the rise of anti-bullying campaigns and why they may be doing more harm than good.

spiked podcast, spiked, 12 November 2013

An Alternate Approach to Stop School Bullying: Fix the Victims

Instead of asking why kids bully, new research focuses on treatment, and seeks to empower victims with ways to cope with peer aggression

Hans Villarica, The Atlantic, 2 November 2011

Should We Rethink Our Anti-Bullying Strategy?

From playground cruelty to the online rumor mill, we're hearing more about bullying than ever, but are we getting better at helping kids and teens cope? TIME looks at the facts behind all those sensational headlines — what we know and don't know about why bullying happens and what we can do to minimize its effects

Meredith Melnick, Time, 28 September 2011

follow the Institute of Ideas

Newsletter

Keep up to date with Institute of Ideas news and events by joining our mailing list.

TICKETS FOR BATTLE 2016 NOW ON SALE
Next year's festival will be packed with more debates like this one. If you would like to come, get your ticket now via our 2016 tickets page.
in association with