Hot on the heels of obesity and passive smoking, the nation’s drinking habits have become a high profile cause for concern. In November last year the Nuffield Council on Bioethics issued a report stating that alcohol consumption ‘has become a huge public health problem in the UK’ and is an ‘area where the Government should do more’. According to the report the annual number of deaths due to medical conditions caused by alcohol in the UK ‘doubled from just over 4,000 in 1991 to over 8,000 in 2005’. According to the Association of Public Health Observatories, alcohol consumption in England contributes to an average reduction in life expectancy of 9.9 months for men and 4.4 months for women. They also point out that alcoholic poisoning, violence and accidents, alcohol-induced pancreatitis, chronic liver disease and stomach cancer all reduce wellbeing and add to the costs of the NHS by £1.7 billion.
It would seem that the government’s attempt to emulate the continent and create a cafe society through 24 hour licensing has failed, with more people vomiting or being violent in public instead. Supermarkets have been slammed for fuelling bad habits through loss leading alcohol promotions, with Julian le Grand, the chairman of Health England, complaining that alcohol has become “like adult candy”, with customers seduced into buying cut-price drink during their weekly shop. But from binge-drinking teenagers to Surrey commuters, from pregnant women to those attempting to conceive, alcohol consumption is a contentious and politicised issue.
What is known about alcohol consumption and health, and how does this compare to what is commonly said by politicians and health officials? What is the evidence that drinking habits in the UK are a significant threat to the nation’s health? Is public drinking a problem of personal health or is it really about public order? Is medical evidence being presented one-sidedly in service of moralistic political objectives?
|Dr Clare Gerada
GP; past chair, Royal College of General Practitioners
|Dr Michael Fitzpatrick
retired GP; author, The Tyranny of Health: doctors and the regulation of lifestyle and Defeating Austism: a damaging delusion
|Dr Peter Marsh
co-director, The Social Issues Research Centre; author of many books including Football Hooliganism and Tribes.
|Dr Gray Smith-Laing
consultant gastroenterologist, Medway Maritime Hospital.
associate fellow, Institute of Ideas
There is so much media interest in alcohol misuse in general, and binge drinking in particular, that it is easy to forget that the majority of the adult population drink responsibly and will continue to do so, whatever drinking messages they are bombarded with.Professor Ian Gilmore, The Guardian, 10 September 2008
A guide to navigating the conflicting findings of medical researchThe Observer, 13 July 2008
The number of people admitted to hospital in England due to drinking alcohol has more than doubled in the past 12 years, NHS figures revealed today.David Batty and agencies, The Guardian, 22 May 2008
“Occasional binge drinking by mother does baby little harm” was a headline that shrieked, because it felt so counter-intuitive.The Times, 17 November 2007
There are no official statistics collected systematically making it impossible to gain a true picture of the role of alcohol in crime at a national level
Social Issues Research Centre, Social Issues Research Centre, 2001
SAB Miller alcohol information websiteSABMiller